Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Mark Bisone's avatar

This article reminded me of a time I accidently started a spat at a party. A mixed group of people, young and old, were fooling around with Alexa, asking it strange questions and delighting in its responses. I told that what they were really pining for was a slave.

They thought I was kidding and laughed it off at first. But as I calmly explained my theory to them further (including the origin of "robot"), they started to get very angry with me. I recognized their anger for what it was: they had glimpsed a mirror, and didn't like what they were seeing. But it was there: the snake that dwells in every human heart, dreaming of the godlike power to command.

It also reminds me of my first (and only) class in Artificial Intelligence. Our very first assignment, preceding all talk of linguistic engines or natural language programming, was Descartes' theory of automata, in which he parses human from animal by defining the latter as purely an i/o mechanism. In drawing that line, he accidentally invented a concept I like to call Marginal Man. And with each successive generation of humanist thought, the margin grew ever slimmer.

And so, now here we have arrived, at the transfer node. Some will turn the page, and fall into the bottomless void beyond the margin. Others might open a different book entirely.

(And don't get me wrong: I'm usually fun at parties.)

1 more comment...

No posts

Ready for more?